From Hostility to Conciliation:  Charting Syed Sheikh Al-Hadi’s Attitude towards Colonialism through the Analysis of al-Imam and al-Ikhwan

Mohamad Tauhid Mohd Bakhit

Mohamad Tauhid Mohd Bakhit Department of Malay Studies, National University of Singapore

Abstract

Syed Sheikh al-Hadi (1867–1934) is a central figure in the study of Islamic reformism in the Malay world. To propagate his ideas, he established three journals: al-Imam (1906–1908), al-Ikhwan (1926–1931) and Saudara (1928–1941). Among these, al-Imam has been the most extensively studied, while al-Ikhwan remains significantly overlooked as a primary source for understanding al-Hadi’s thoughts. This neglect disregards critical insights into potential shifts and developments in his ideas, especially since al-Ikhwan was published nearly two decades after al-Imam ceased publication. Specifically, this gap has led to unsatisfactory conclusions regarding al-Hadi’s attitude towards the British colonisers. Without accounting for any shift that had taken place over the decades, several existing studies either depict al-Hadi as fervently and consistently anti-colonial or conclude otherwise, directly contradicting each other. Through a textual analysis of al-Ikhwan and comparison with his earlier writings in al-Imam, this paper argues that a significant shift in his stance towards the colonisers had occurred from hostility in al-Imam to conciliation in al-Ikhwan. Using a socio-historical analysis, it further demonstrates that this shift can be explained by the differing contexts in which al-Hadi was writing for each periodical. This highlights al-Hadi’s critical approach to reform—one that was not merely an imitation of prominent reformists elsewhere, but firmly grounded in the circumstances he faced.

References

Abdul Rahman Haji Ismail. (2003). Syed Syeikh al-Hadi: Penggerak kebangkitan Melayu abad ke-20. In Sohaimi Abdul Aziz (Ed.), Cendekia dan sasterawan ulung (pp. 9–36). Universiti Sains Malaysia
Abu Bakar Hamzah. (1981). al-Imam: Its role in Malay society, 1906-1908. Media Cendekiawan Sdn. Bhd.
Ahmad Dzulfahmi Muhamad, & Mohammad Redzuan Othman. (2020). Pengislahan sistem pendidikan Islam di tanah Melayu: Peranan mudir Madrasah al-Mashoor alIslamiah Pulau Pinang, 1916-1957. Journal of Al-Tamaddun, 15(1), 133–145. https://doi.org/10.22452/JAT.vol15no1.9
Alatas, Syed Farid. (2005). Ideology and utopia in the thought of Syed Shaykh al-Hady. Faculty of Arts & Social Sciences, Department of Sociology, National University of Singapore.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1907). Menuntut ketinggian akan anak-anak negeri. al-Imam, 25–31.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1927a). Akhbar dalam negeri. al-Ikhwan, 1(10), 202–204.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1927b). Akhbar luar negeri: Bin Sa’ud dan Kerajaan Inggeris. al-Ikhwan, 1(11), 219–223.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1929a). Ulama’ di Kelantan dengan al-Ikhwan dan Saudara. alIkhwan, 3(7), 215–220.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1929b). Tafsir al-Quran: Surah An-Naziat, sambungan al-IkhwanPenggal 6 Jilid 3. al-Ikhwan, 3(7), 195–203.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (1930). Apa dalam majalah guru. al-Ikhwan, 4(5), 141–146.
al-Hadi, Syed Sheikh. (2018). Kritikan Pandita Za’ba terhadap ‘teriak sebenar’ dan suran balasan daripada al-Ikhwan. In A. Gordon (Ed.), Seruan islah Syed Syeikh al-Hadi. (p. 167–179). Islamic Renaissance Front Berhad. (Original work published 1926).
al-Hady, Syed Alwi. (1999). The life of my father. In A. Gordon (Ed.), The real cry of Syed Syeikh al-Hadi (pp. 69–84). Malaysian Sociological Research Institute.
al-Hady, Syed Mohamed Alwi. (1999). Syed Syeikh: Through the prism of a child’s eyes & the al-Hady clan. In A. Gordon (Ed.), The real cry of Syed Syeikh al-Hadi (pp. 85–108). Malaysian Sociological Research Institute.
Azyumardi Azra. (1999). The transmission of al-Manar’s reformism to the Malay-Indonesian world: The cases of al-Imam and al-Munir. Studia Islamika, 6(3), 75–100. https://doi.org/10.15408/sdi.v6i3.723
Bashiri, I. (2023). Jamāl al-Dīn al-Afghānī. EBSCO Information Services. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/jamal-al-din-al-afghani
Carr, E.H. (1986). What is history?. The Macmillan Press Ltd.
Freire, P. (2000). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.
Gordon, A. (2018). Seruan islah Syed Shaykh al-Hady. (Mohd Rashidi Nashruddin &
Shuhaib Ar Rumy Ismail, Trans.). Islamic Renaissance Front Berhad.
Haddad, Y. (2005). Muhammad Abduh: Pioneer of Islamic reform. In Ali Rahmena (Ed.), Pioneers of Islamic revival (pp. 30–63). Zed Books.
Hafiz Zakariya. (2017). Colonialism, society and reforms in Malaya: A comparative evaluation of Shaykh Tahir Jalaluddin and Syed Shaykh Ahmad Al-Hady. Intellectual Discourse, 25(Special Issue), 477–501. https://doi.org/10.31436/id.v25iSpecialIs.1054
Hafiz Zakariya & Wiwin Oktasari. (2017). From Riau to Singapore: A content analysis of the Rushdiah Club’s major published writings (ca. 1890-1950). International Journal of Islamic and Civilizational Studies, 4(3). 11–25. https://doi.org/10.11113/umran2017.4n3.162
Hashim Ismail. (2019). Syed Syeikh al-Hadi dan jaringan pengaruh pemikirannya. In Mohamad Mokhtar Abu Hassan & Mohd Hanafi Ibrahim (Eds.), Pembaharu semangat Islam dan sosial (pp. 28–57). Produksi Nur-Johan Sdn. Bhd.
Ibrahim Abu Bakar. (1994). Islamic modernism in Malaya: The life and thought of Sayid Shekh al-Hadi, 1867-1934. University of Malaya Press.
Ibrahim Abu Bakar. (1991). The divine decree and determination in al-Hadi’s thought. Islamiyyat, 12, 15–24.
Keddie, N.R. (2005). Sayyid Jamal al-Din ‘al-Afghani’. In Ali Rahmena (Ed.), Pioneers of Islamic revival. (pp. 11–29). Zed Books.
Marina Merican. (1960). Sayed Shaikh al-Hadi dan pendapatnya mengenai kemajuan kaum perempuan (sebagai tersiar didalam majallah al-Ikhwan) [Academic Exercise, Universiti Malaya].
Meriboute, Z. (2009). Islam’s fateful path: The critical choices facing modern Muslims. (J. King, Trans.). I.B. Tauris.
Mohamed Fairoz Ahmad. (2010). Orientalism and integrative history: A study of an early 20th century Islamic periodical in Singapore. [Master’s thesis, National University of Singapore]. ScholarBank@NUS. http://scholarbank.nus.edu.sg/handle/10635/18808
Muhammad Tamim Abdul Qadir. (1927). al-Ikhwan dan keberhentiannya. al-Ikhwan, 1(10), 185–187.
Shaharom TM Sulaiman. (2003). Jaringan pengaruh luar terhadap pemikiran dan sikap Syed Syeikh al-Hadi. In Sohaimi Abdul Aziz (Ed.), Cendekia dan sasterawan ulung(pp. 58–72). Universiti Sains Malaysia.
Smith, T.W. (1994). Concepts and methods in the study of anger, hostility, and health. In A.W. Siegman & T.W. Smith (Eds.), Anger, hostility, and the heart (pp. 23–42). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Talib Samat. (1992). Syed Sheikh al-Hadi: Sasterawan progresif Melayu. Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
Talib Samat. (2019). Biografi Syed Syeikh bin Syed Ahmad al-Hadi. In Mohamad Mokhtar Abu Hassan & Mohd Hanafi Ibrahim (Eds.), Pembaharu semangat Islam dan sosial, pp. 3–27. Produksi Nur-Johan Sdn. Bhd.
Tan, L. (1999). Syed Shaykh: His life & times. In A. Gordon (Ed.), The real cry of Syed Syeikh al-Hadi (pp. 109–162). Malaysian Sociological Research Institute.
Wan Suhana Wan Sulong. (2003). Saudara (1928-1941): Its contribution to the debate on issues in Malay society and the development of a Malay world-view [Doctoral dissertation, University of Hull]. https://hull-repository.worktribe.com/output/4212293
Wan Suhana Wan Sulong. (2006). Saudara (1928–1941): Continuity and change in the Malay society. Intellectual Discourse: 14(2), 179–202. https://doi.org/10.31436/id.v14i2.97
Zainal Abidin Ahmad. (1927). Kemiskinan orang Melayu. al-Ikhwan, 1(8), 151–154